I'm going to buy a new laptop. Let us assume that its primary use will be for studying at DIKU. What should I get? Which operating system should I run?

This question is marked "community wiki".

asked 06 Jan '12, 15:24

Troels%20Henriksen's gravatar image

Troels Henri... ♦
5521110
accept rate: 66%

edited 13 Jan '12, 15:21

Martin%20Dybdal's gravatar image

Martin Dybdal ♦♦
1.1k123282


Buying a new laptop 101:

  • First important decider: Does it have the right size? Weight matters a lot if you are to haul your laptop with you every day. Make sure it has a weight that you can stand to haul along. Also make sure it has a size that makes it possible to toss it around.
  • Second important decider: Can it stand a beating? Expect to use your laptop a lot while at DIKU. Don't go buy something cheap plastic-stuff because it will only last months. It is better to live off of noodles some more and get good stuff. You are not out for raw calculation speed, but durability. It needs to withstand that you get bumped into on the train and that you fall on your bike in the snow in the winter. There is also wear and tear on the laptop itself from normal use. You will be amazed how few manufacturers that actually build their laptops for 24/7 operation.
  • Third important decider: Heat sink exhaust. If you expect to sit with your laptop in your lap and not on a table, it has to be built such that the heat sinks exhaust is not down in your thighs. Otherwise it gets uncomfortable as soon as you hit the courses that use Haskell...
  • Fourth important decider: Screen, Keyboard and mouse input. You can't just go out and buy a different keyboard or screen for your laptop, so they have to be somewhat good. I'd recommend going for a full-size keyboard since they are nicer to type on. Also, if you can't stand a trackpad, don't buy the laptop with exactly that trackpad. If you want a trackpoint, buy a thinkpad (the red dot on Thinkpads - also called the "cat tongue" or the "clit"). Finally, if the screen is too small for your taste or has bad resolution then you are stuck with it.
  • Fifth decider: RAM and CPU speed. It usually matters less. Go for lots of RAM first and then go for CPU speed. If you are to do lots of heavyweight computation, getting a fast CPU can help. The GPU of the beast might also matter if you do lots of image synthesis or want to play with hardware accel of computations. Get something with some cores though so you can get into the modern world of parallel computing right away.
  • Sixth decider: Battery life. If you plan on hacking lots in places where power is not available (on the train, say) be sure to get a laptop that can work for hours without a power plug.

Recommended laptops are usually:

  • Lenovo Thinkpads: Expensive beasts, but oh so worth it. The best keyboards on laptops in my opinion. They can dual-boot to Windows/Linux easily and Linux hardware support is friggin' excellent. They have nice heat profiles and they are work-horses. Their internal hexagon titanium skeleton protects them a lot.
  • Apple Laptops: Even more expensive beasts. Expect software to cost money if you buy one. Slightly worse keyboard than the Lenovo. Slightly worse heat profile. But the chassis is one piece of aluminum and can withstand beatings quite well. May be slightly harder to get software to work on the OSX system which is reminiscent of BSD Unix.

Not recommended:

  • Anything by Acer - The kings and priests of plastic.
  • Zepto, when they existed - The prince and nuns of plastic.
link

answered 07 Jan '12, 12:57

jlouis's gravatar image

jlouis
6163
accept rate: 50%

edited 07 Jan '12, 13:01

3

Great points. I think battery life should be given more credit though. It is very nice to have when sitting in a train or plane or even just the couch.

(07 Jan '12, 22:00) soerend soerend's gravatar image
2

"You are not out for raw calculation speed, but durability." - this is very correct. If the time comes and you need to do a lot of number crunching for your project, what you really want is to run the program on one of DIKUs servers (sci- og tuxray-machines). If you need to do GPU computations, DIKU also have servers with CUDA/OpenCL graphics cards you can get access to (ask your supervisor).

(07 Jan '12, 23:14) Martin Dybdal ♦♦ Martin%20Dybdal's gravatar image

Jeg ville købe en brugt IBM T61 fra Brugtecomputere.dk. Den koster kr. 2.395 og har et års garanti, 15.4" TFT-skærm, 4G RAM, 100G harddisk, 2.00GHz Core Duo og CD/DVD-læser/brænder. De er billigere og kraftigere end nye netbooks, billigere og mere holdbare end nye computere med samme specifikationer.

Fordele:

  • Billig, behagelig og holdbar.
  • I rigtig god stand, på trods af at de er brugt.
  • Det er svært, hvis ikke umuligt, at finde T61 som ny.
  • Har et højskærmformat som ikke produceres mere.

Ulemper:

  • Batterilevetiden er 1-2 timer.
  • Kan ikke konfigureres som saml-selv-computere.
  • Grafikkort og lydkort er gennemsnitlige.
  • Der er ikke tale om en UltraBook, så vægten/tykkelsen er også gennemsnitlig.

Man kan læse om hvad man kan forvente ved de forskellige kvalitetsgrader (1-3) som benyttes om batterierne. Om nødvendigt kan man købe et nyt batteri separat. Jeg har ikke selv følt behovet.

link

answered 08 Jan '12, 00:30

Simon%20Shine's gravatar image

Simon Shine ♦
384310
accept rate: 27%

edited 24 Aug '12, 16:57

Although I am bit confused by the fact that you, Troels, of all people are asking to purchase a new laptop, I thought you just obtained one.

But the real answer depends on what you intend of your laptop. If you have no trouble operating a small and slightly slow machine, a Netbook is a brilliant choice, money wise. Otherwise go for a ThinkPad.

Alternatively, get a job wherein your employers gives you a free laptop avoids you the agony of having to choose. Because somehow we always pick something where soon after believe we could have picked a better choice.

I keep regretting not getting an Intel i7 for my desktop.

link

answered 06 Jan '12, 16:34

Brainfuck's gravatar image

Brainfuck
4081212
accept rate: 60%

-5

Jeg er ret glad for min commodore 64, basic og assembly er jo faktisk det eneste man har brug for. Så er styresystemet også overflødigt.

link

answered 06 Jan '12, 16:05

Pilen's gravatar image

Pilen
30813
accept rate: 35%

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×122
×3

Asked: 06 Jan '12, 15:24

Seen: 2,107 times

Last updated: 24 Aug '12, 16:57

powered by OSQA